In 1999, when I served on the pastoral team of Clear Creek Community Church, we engaged a well-know campaign consultant. The experience was mediocre at best. It felt slick and [...]
Why does your church need more than a church capital campaign? Because pastors and church leaders and good-hearted church attenders are tired of the "campaign fatigue" brought upon by the repetitive traditional approach to raising funds.
Stop Campaigning and Start Discipling
When church leaders are unaware of better alternatives, they get stuck in the traditional fundraising cycles, back to back (typically in 3-year cycles) designed to raise money without adequate vision, leadership development or disciple-making strategies in place. Two years ago, the Auxano team felt led by God to address the sticky issues of this industry. I personally felt called to be a part of the solution and not just a naysayer regarding the old-school approaches. We are getting some extraordinary results from taking a different path; a better and more holistic approach. Here is one of our stories by Todd McMichen:
The Story of Mainstreet Church
Recently, Auxano was engaged by Mainstreet Church in the greater Toledo, Ohio area to help rethink how they would continue to fund their vision. Under the leadership of Lead Pastor, Marty Pennington, the church had taken a leap of faith, constructed a new campus, and relocated to the new facilities enabling them to build relationships that move more people to full devotion to Christ. However, this new level brought about new resourcing challenges. The church had a healthy debt load that needed to be addressed and an ever-increasing cycle of one campaign after another. Each campaign resulted in lower participation percentages, a reduction in cash offerings, and smaller financial commitments by their members. Mainstreet was experiencing “campaign fatigue.” Campaign fatigue sets in when members of the church become weary of the repetitive cycle of campaign after campaign with no apparent end in sight. For both leaders and members, fatigue quickly grows into frustration and weariness. The church was at a resourcing crossroads and had several challenges that needed to be overcome.
- How do we continue to fund the vision?
- How do we stop the campaign cycle?
- How do we re-energize leaders?
- How do we disciple believers in the area of generosity?
- How do we increase the number of people who are financially contributing to the vision of the church?
So what did Campaigns by Auxano recommend? Stop Campaigning and Start Discipling! The church courageously hit the pause button on their next campaign and developed a comprehensive discipleship plan around their “give fully” spiritual mark. They identified four stages of “giving fully” for Christ followers: emerging, engaged, growing, and generous. Members were challenged to assess their stage and take the essential steps to go to the next stage. The clear challenge was to “grow up” in the area of generosity. For some that meant to start tithing. For others it meant that God was calling them to become generous “above and beyond” givers. Mainstreet’s prayer was to create a culture of generosity among a broader base of their membership and provide a break in the campaign cycle. So what happened? Despite enduring the worst weather on record and its impact on their Sunday morning attendance, the church had amazing spiritual and numerical results:
- 38% immediate giving increase for the first 12 weeks of the generosity initiative
- 16% sustainable increase in budget giving beyond the first 12 weeks of the generosity initiative
- more people contributing financially to the work of the church than ever before
- a new generosity culture language that is empowering discipleship and making the mission transferable
- a clearly designed and supported growth pathway from being an emerging giver to a generous disciple
When you bring the entire staff together, articulate a clear vision, and create a comprehensive discipleship strategy, churches can grow a generous culture that will produce immediate and sustainable results. Of course, you can keep campaigning if that is more fun!